LEADERSHIP incompetence can have a detrimental impact on organisations. When leaders are ineffective in their roles, it often leads to a lack of direction, poor decision-making and a demotivated workforce.

This article will explore the consequences of leadership incompetence and discuss strategies for improving leadership skills.

One of the main consequences of leadership incompetence is a lack of direction within the organisation. When leaders cannot articulate a clear vision and set goals for the team, it can result in confusion and a lack of focus.

Employees may not understand their roles or what is expected of them, which can lead to inefficiency and frustration. Such leaders who lack direction and vision often shift between various projects, confusing the workforce.

Poor decision-making is another significant consequence of leadership incompetence. The organisation’s performance is affected when leaders do not have the ability to make informed decisions.

Decisions may be based on personal biases or incomplete information, leading to poor outcomes and missed opportunities. This can erode trust in leadership and negatively affect the organisation. Effective leaders have high critical thinking skills, often leading to better decisions.

Keep Reading

Leadership incompetence can also result in a demotivated workforce. When employees feel incompetent leaders are leading them; they feel demoralised. They often feel unsupported, undervalued, and unappreciated, decreasing job satisfaction and productivity.

A lack of confidence in leadership can lead to high turnover rates as employees seek opportunities elsewhere. Most professional-level staff care about who is leading the organisation and how competent such a person is.

A toxic work environment caused by incompetent leaders can lead to stress, anxiety, and negative effects on employees. This includes increased absenteeism, decreased productivity, and high turnover rates.

Toxicity can manifest through bullying, harassment, discrimination, or micro-management resulting in issues like depression, anxiety and burnout escalating.

Failing to address a toxic work environment risks the organisation’s reputation and leads to losing valuable employees.

Incompetent leaders can push away talented employees, who feel frustrated by the organisation’s lack of effective leadership and guidance. Talented individuals seek leaders who inspire them and offer avenues for growth and development.

When leaders fail to provide these opportunities, talented employees may seek employment elsewhere. The departure of such valuable employees can be costly for organisations, resulting in reduced productivity, higher recruitment expenses, and a loss of valuable institutional knowledge.

Something can be done about leadership incompetence. One approach is to provide leadership training and development programmes. These programmes can help leaders develop essential skills such as communication, decision-making, and conflict resolution.

Ongoing coaching and mentoring can also be beneficial in helping leaders improve their performance. Before investing in leadership training, you need to be sure that the people entrusted with leadership can be trained for improvements.

Organisations often waste money putting people through training when such people cannot improve even after training.

Another strategy is to foster a culture of feedback and continuous improvement.  Creating a system that encourages open and honest communication enables leaders to receive feedback from their teams and make necessary adjustments to their leadership style.

For such feedback to be efffective the leaders themselves need to create a safe and supportive environment where employees feel comfortable, providing feedback can contribute to a stronger leadership team.

A study by McKinsey shows that leaders, who use supportive and consultative leadership styles create a better team environment, leading to higher psychological safety.

The same study found that authoritarian leadership styles negatively correlate with psychological safety.

Additionally, organisations can consider implementing a leadership competency framework. This framework outlines the skills, behaviours, and knowledge that effective leaders should possess.

By aligning leadership development programmes and performance evaluations with this framework, organisations can set clear expectations for leaders and track their progress.

This is probably one of Zimbabwe's most underutilised approaches to developing leaders. Most of the leadership training is generic and classroom-type, far removed from the realities the organisation is facing.

In conclusion, leadership incompetence can have significant consequences for organisations. It can result in a lack of direction, poor decision-making, and a demotivated workforce.

However, by implementing strategies such as leadership training, fostering a culture of feedback, and defining leadership competencies, organisations can address leadership incompetence and cultivate strong and effective leaders.

  • Nguwi is an occupational psychologist, data scientist, speaker and managing consultant at Industrial Psychology Consultants (Pvt) Ltd, a management and HR consulting firm. — https://www.linkedin.com/in/memorynguwi/ Phone +263 24 248 1 946-48/ 2290 0276, cell number +263 772 356 361 or e-mail: mnguwi@ipcconsultants.com or visit ipcconsultants.com.

 
Previous article
Analysis of Monetary Policy resolutions to stabilise ZiG