Opinion
Patients first: Why ZADHR supports the medical aid reforms
ZADHR ·

PAYING for medical aid should bring peace of mind, not the fear of being unable to afford treatment when illness strikes.
Yet for many Zimbabweans, making monthly contributions does not guarantee that their medical expenses will be fully covered.
When the hospital bill arrives, patients and their families may still be left struggling to meet the shortfall.
At the heart of this problem lies a fundamental question: should a medical aid society that collects members’ contributions to finance their healthcare also own and operate hospitals, pharmacies and other facilities from which healthcare is purchased?
When the same institution controls the funding and competes to provide the service, conflict of interest can arise, patient choice can be constrained and the interests of members risk being pushed aside.
The Zimbabwe Association of Doctors for Human Rights (ZADHR) supports the proposed reforms to separate the financing of healthcare from its provision.
This is not simply a debate about business ownership.
It is about accountability for members’ contributions, fairness in the healthcare market, the quality-of-care patients receive and the protection of the right to healthcare under section 76 of the Constitution of Zimbabwe.
Medical aid must put patients first.
The proposed reforms offer an opportunity to restore that principle by ensuring that medical aid societies focus on financing members’ healthcare, while independent providers compete to deliver the care patients need.
With appropriate safeguards and a carefully managed transition, Zimbabwe can move towards a system that places patients’ interests, dignity and access to good quality healthcare at its centre.
Where we are today
Medical aid covers a small and shrinking share of Zimbabweans.
Industry figures presented to Parliament in April put coverage at about 8% of the population, with more than 90% paying for care out of their own pockets.
Members typically contribute between US$55 and US$65 a month.
Over the past two decades, the largest societies have become much more than funders.
They have bought or built hospitals, clinics, pharmacies, laboratories, imaging centres, dental practices and ambulance services.
Researchers at EQUINET documented this as early as 2010.
They found that most acquisitions were existing facilities rather than adding new capacity to the health system.
Instead of containing costs, as promised, the move coincided with rising costs.
In practice, a single society can now sit on both sides of almost every step in a patient’s care.
It holds the money, writes the price list, approves or rejects claims and owns facilities that compete with the very providers it pays.
Independent doctors, hospitals and pharmacies must, therefore, negotiate their fees with, and wait to be paid by, a direct competitor.
This creates a structural conflict of interest, even where the people making decisions act in good faith.
Patients who cannot cover the gap often end up in already overstretched public hospitals.
The cost of this arrangement is, therefore, carried by the whole health system, not only by medical aid members.
Meanwhile, reimbursement rates in many schemes have not kept pace with the real cost of running a practice, which inflation, currency instability and imported equipment and consumables have all pushed up.
When a society pays less than care actually costs, the difference does not vanish.
It is passed on to the patient as a shortfall and too often the provider, not the payer, is held responsible.
What the reform proposes
The Health and Child Care ministry has proposed amending section 14 of the Medical Services (Medical Aid Societies) Regulations, 2000, SI 330/2000, as amended by (SI 35/2004 and SI 58/2025) the regulations that govern medical aid societies.
The amendment would bar societies from owning or operating healthcare facilities such as hospitals, clinics and pharmacies.
Societies would return to their core function: pooling members’ contributions and purchasing care on their behalf. Those that already own facilities would be required to divest.
The proposal has been before Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Health, which heard submissions from the industry in April 2026.
Funders, led by the Association of Healthcare Funders of Zimbabwe and Cimas Health Group, have campaigned hard against it.
Civil society organisations, including the Community Working Group on Health, and many doctors have spoken in its favor.
Why ZADHR supports the reform
Medical aid exists to finance care, not to build business empires
Contributions are paid to protect members when they fall ill, and societies hold non-profit status for exactly that reason.
Keeping sensible reserves is responsible management.
Using members’ contributions as capital for commercial expansion, without giving those members any ownership or say, is something else entirely.
The conflict of interest is structural, not personal
A society that owns clinics has every incentive to steer members towards its own facilities, and to pay independent providers less.
It can approve claims quickly at its own pharmacy and slowly elsewhere or treat its own laboratory as the default.
EQUINET’s research found that only 11% of plans fully reimbursed services from providers outside the society’s own network.
That is not managed care; it is managed choice.
Patient choice and continuity of care suffer
Patients with chronic illnesses, pregnancies or cancer often need a doctor they trust over many years.
When a society nudges or forces members towards its own facilities, that relationship is broken.
Choice of provider is not a luxury. It is part of good, safe medicine.
Quality must be judged by outcomes, not throughput
A facility can treat large numbers of patients and still deliver poor care if consultations are rushed and staff are stretched thin.
When the payer owns the provider, no independent party checks whether members receive the standard of care their contributions pay for.
A purchaser that stands apart from providers can set and enforce standards across all of them, from waiting times and staffing to clinical results.
Fair competition protects patients Independent doctors, hospitals and pharmacies are being squeezed out, especially in smaller towns.
Fewer independent providers means fewer options, longer distances and, ultimately, higher prices.
Smaller medical aid societies, which do not own facilities, are also disadvantaged against vertically integrated rivals.
Claims of lower costs have never been independently verified
Integrated societies say their own facilities are cheaper.
If that is true, the evidence should be published and independently audited so that members, regulators and Parliament can judge it for themselves.
So far, it has not been. Because societies are spending money that belongs to their members, the burden of proof rests with them.
Shortfalls are a policy choice, not a law of nature
A scheme whose premiums rise with costs, but whose reimbursement rates lag behind them, will always leave members with a gap.
When that same scheme also earns revenue from its own facilities, the incentive to fix its rates weakens.
Removing the ownership link pushes societies to compete on what members value most: how fully and fairly they pay for care.
Good governance requires clear lines
The sector has suffered serious governance scandals, including revelations in 2014 of extraordinary executive pay at one of the largest societies.
Complex group structures, with subsidiaries spanning hospitals, pharmacies and property, make oversight harder for members and regulators alike.
A society that only funds care is far easier to supervise.
This is international best practice
Separating the purchaser of care from the provider is a widely used principle of health financing.
It is also the foundation on which Zimbabwe must build a fair National Health Insurance scheme.
Getting the private funding market right now prepares the ground for universal health coverage.
Answering the industry’s objections
The funders have warned of a “collapse cascade” if the reform passes. Their concerns deserve a serious answer.
“Without our facilities, tariffs and premiums will rise.”
Societies already have a powerful tool to control costs: the tariffs they negotiate and the claims they approve.
A strong, independent purchaser can bargain hard with every provider. It does not need to own the hospital to do so.
If integration truly lowered costs, the savings should already show in lower premiums and fewer shortfalls. Members do not see them.
“We built facilities because the market failed.”
Medicine shortages and tariff inflation are real problems.
The answer is better regulation, strategic purchasing and stronger public facilities, not turning funders into competitors.
A temporary fix for market failure has become a permanent conflict of interest.
“Kaiser Permanente and Bupa do it.”
These organisations operate in markets with strong, independent regulators, transparent accounts and enforceable consumer protections.
Zimbabwe has only just placed medical aid societies under the Insurance and Pensions Commission (IPEC), through section 2 of the Insurance and Pensions Commission Amendment Act of 2026 gazetted in April 2026, and that oversight is still being built.
Copying the business model before the safeguards are proven is a risk to members, not a reform.
“Jobs and services will be lost.”
Divestment does not mean closure. A clinic sold to independent doctors, a nursing group or an investor continues to employ staff and treat patients.
What changes is who owns it, and whether its owner also controls the purse.
A phased, supervised transition can protect both jobs and continuity of care.
ZADHR agrees with the industry on one point: the reform should be implemented carefully, with a sensible transition period and independent oversight.
What we ask of Parliament and the ministry
ZADHR urges Parliament and the Ministry of Health and Child Care to:
lPass the amendment prohibiting medical aid societies from owning or operating healthcare facilities.
lSet a clear, phased divestment timeline, with protection for staff and continuity of care for patients.
lMake IPEC’s new oversight count. The Insurance and Pensions Commission Amendment Act of 2026 places medical aid societies under IPEC under section 2.
lIPEC must be resourced to audit societies and their subsidiaries, enforce solvency and protect members, working hand in hand with the ministry on standards of care.
lRequire transparent reporting, including audited accounts, claims ratios and how reserves are invested, published annually for members.
lReview the tariff framework so that reimbursement reflects the real cost of care, ending the shortfall trap for patients.
lProtect members’ choice of provider, so that no member is penalised for seeing a doctor or facility of their choice.
Zimbabweans who pay into medical aid are entitled to know that their contributions are used to pay for their care, and for nothing else.
Separating the funding of care from its provision is a simple, well-established principle that protects that promise.
ZADHR urges Parliament to adopt it, and to return the patient to the centre of a system that exists to serve them.